I'm not too big a fan of using (strong) acid to treat metal. Depending on its potency, it can be very hazardous (especially to skin and respiratory organ health), so it's definitely not for the clumsy. It's also much less controllable than using good old wire brush, file, and sandpaper. For rust-removal, non-acidic solutions do a fine job (see previous post).
That said, acid has notable benefits. It works rapidly and -- which is really the only reason I use it -- it eats away material in places that manual tools cannot reach. I had to derust the pipe in the picture below (part of my bike's engine-cooling system).
The engine-facing side was in especially bad condition because (whilst installed) it was virtually impossible to clean. Chrome gone, deeply entrenched rust everywhere. Manual tools did a good job cleaning it, but they did not reach underneath the welded-on attachment with the screw. Soaking in Evapo-Rust overnight worked well, but I still couldn't tell how clean the hidden area was. To ensure full removal of rust and any other deposits, I decided to use acid.
In NZ, hydrochloric acid (also called 'muriatic acid') is easily available. For example, Bunnings sells a Bondall product with 320g/L HCl, which makes it a ~28% acid solution by volume (currently ~$16 for 1L, regular price).
Hydrochloric acid isn't actually ideal for treating steel because the chemical reaction that takes place during immersion leaves the metal highly susceptible to rust-(re-)development. Phosphoric acid on the other hand does not, but unfortunately it's harder to obtain. DIY stores do not sell it at all (in NZ).
Preparation of a full set-up is key:
1) Get a plastic container for the acid bath (I went with 2L icecream). Do not use it indoors! The chemical reaction produces highly corrosive fumes that will damage your respiratory organs!
2) Ensure access to fresh water (hose or bucket) to be able to rinse the acid off the metal.
3) Prepare another container with alkaline solution. You'll need it to immerse the metal and actually neutralise the acid. Mix 1 part baking soda and 10 parts water.
4) Use rubber gloves, eye protection, and skin cover. If possible, set a timer. And, again, do not use the acid indoors.
NOTE: If you need to dilute an acid, remember the saying "do like you oughta, add acid to water". Otherwise, the exothermic reaction can be violent.
For my own project, I prepared the pipe by taping off both ends to prevent the acid from damaging the inside (which was pristine). Rubber from old gloves and masking tape (very firmly tied around) did a great job sealing the openings, nothing got in. Having moved the entire set-up to the deck, I placed the pipe in the ice cream container (screw pointing up) and poured the acid, just enough to get in under the attachment without touching the threaded part. The metal began to throw bubbles almost immediately, a bit like strongly carbonated mineral water. Checking every 5 minutes, a quarter hour turned out to be enough. The pipe looked like it was covered in zinc, underneath the attachment too. A good water rinse, then immersion in alkaline solution. Bubbles (indicating that neutralisation is ongoing) ceased after a few minutes. Another water rinse, and that was that.
The metal surface began to develop flash-rust after only about 20-30 minutes, so HCl really isn't ideal. Fortunately, that issue can be addressed quite easily: dump the part in Evapo-Rust (and leave it in till you're ready to process it).
As for storing the acid for future use, pour it back in the original bottle. That said, don't mix used and virgin acid. (I use glass jars.) Make sure you label everything. If you have kids, store the containers out of reach.
That said, acid has notable benefits. It works rapidly and -- which is really the only reason I use it -- it eats away material in places that manual tools cannot reach. I had to derust the pipe in the picture below (part of my bike's engine-cooling system).
The engine-facing side was in especially bad condition because (whilst installed) it was virtually impossible to clean. Chrome gone, deeply entrenched rust everywhere. Manual tools did a good job cleaning it, but they did not reach underneath the welded-on attachment with the screw. Soaking in Evapo-Rust overnight worked well, but I still couldn't tell how clean the hidden area was. To ensure full removal of rust and any other deposits, I decided to use acid.
In NZ, hydrochloric acid (also called 'muriatic acid') is easily available. For example, Bunnings sells a Bondall product with 320g/L HCl, which makes it a ~28% acid solution by volume (currently ~$16 for 1L, regular price).
Hydrochloric acid isn't actually ideal for treating steel because the chemical reaction that takes place during immersion leaves the metal highly susceptible to rust-(re-)development. Phosphoric acid on the other hand does not, but unfortunately it's harder to obtain. DIY stores do not sell it at all (in NZ).
Preparation of a full set-up is key:
1) Get a plastic container for the acid bath (I went with 2L icecream). Do not use it indoors! The chemical reaction produces highly corrosive fumes that will damage your respiratory organs!
2) Ensure access to fresh water (hose or bucket) to be able to rinse the acid off the metal.
3) Prepare another container with alkaline solution. You'll need it to immerse the metal and actually neutralise the acid. Mix 1 part baking soda and 10 parts water.
4) Use rubber gloves, eye protection, and skin cover. If possible, set a timer. And, again, do not use the acid indoors.
NOTE: If you need to dilute an acid, remember the saying "do like you oughta, add acid to water". Otherwise, the exothermic reaction can be violent.
For my own project, I prepared the pipe by taping off both ends to prevent the acid from damaging the inside (which was pristine). Rubber from old gloves and masking tape (very firmly tied around) did a great job sealing the openings, nothing got in. Having moved the entire set-up to the deck, I placed the pipe in the ice cream container (screw pointing up) and poured the acid, just enough to get in under the attachment without touching the threaded part. The metal began to throw bubbles almost immediately, a bit like strongly carbonated mineral water. Checking every 5 minutes, a quarter hour turned out to be enough. The pipe looked like it was covered in zinc, underneath the attachment too. A good water rinse, then immersion in alkaline solution. Bubbles (indicating that neutralisation is ongoing) ceased after a few minutes. Another water rinse, and that was that.
The metal surface began to develop flash-rust after only about 20-30 minutes, so HCl really isn't ideal. Fortunately, that issue can be addressed quite easily: dump the part in Evapo-Rust (and leave it in till you're ready to process it).
As for storing the acid for future use, pour it back in the original bottle. That said, don't mix used and virgin acid. (I use glass jars.) Make sure you label everything. If you have kids, store the containers out of reach.


No comments:
Post a Comment